Just this guy, you know?

  • 0 Posts
  • 15 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle
  • zaphod@lemmy.catoGaming@beehaw.orgLet's discuss: Mass Effect
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    4 months ago

    It’s all about tone. The original comment was incredibly combative and hyperbolic (“I utterly loathe Mass Effect. I consider it one of the worst pieces of science-fiction ever created.”) so much so that it would easily be mistaken for flamebait given the thread was likely to attract fans of the series.

    It certainly didn’t strike me as the start of an open-minded conversation.

    But in hindsight I should’ve just downvoted and moved on rather than commenting as I did, so that’s on me.



  • zaphod@lemmy.catoGaming@beehaw.orgLet's discuss: Mass Effect
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    Ahh yes, the old “sticks and stones” defense that completely ignores human nature and basic decency. I use the same logic when I tell other people their babies are ugly. “Look, if you ask me your kid is an eyesore but it’s just my opinion so I don’t know why you’re so mad right now…”









  • No, I used another example of a leader who did both good things and horrible things as an illustration of how you don’t get to use the good stuff to erase the horrible stuff, thereby exposing the flaw in your apologetic reasoning.

    Modi is a demagogue that’s stoked the worst aspects of Hindu nationalism and encouraged racism and violence in the name of power. Any socioeconomic gains under his rule don’t erase those facts.

    That you attempt to use the tactic of equating criticism of Modi and the BJP with criticism of India, the country, as a method of stoking nationalistic anger toward those opposed to their rule only further illustrates how Modi and his supporters have, charitably, fascist tendencies.




  • Disregard everything below. I mistook the comment about neo-liberalism for a quote from this guy.

    I’m leaving the text up for context, but this criticism is misdirected.

    ==

    It says everything you need to know that he (I suspect deliberately) confuses neo-liberal for left-wing ideology.

    Neo-liberal = capitalist with a smoking jacket and a fancy degree on the wall.

    SV is absolute rife with anarcho-capitalist ideology. I can only dream of a version of SV that actually carries some measure of economically liberal ideology.

    My guess is this guy is confusing social liberalism with economic liberalism. But, of course, that’s the entire right wing schtick these days.