• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 6 months ago
cake
Cake day: March 17th, 2024

help-circle
  • prototype_g2@lemmy.mltoComics@lemmy.mlCommunism
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    30
    arrow-down
    15
    ·
    10 days ago

    It’s funny because I’m pretty sure you haven’t lived in a communist country either. So you’re arguing that lack of personal experience invalidates all arguments in favour of communism, but your lack of personal experience living in a communist country somehow doesn’t invalidate your arguments against communism. Yup, perfectly consistent.




  • And who will create the automaton? How do we select people to maintain the automaton that will play the role of government?

    That automatic government has to be created by a group of people. How do you plant to select them? The government automaton would also need to be maintained, as it is impossible for the authors of the machine to predict what humanity is going to look like 500 years from now. How do you select those?

    The logic of “code is impartial, therefore code should be law” is flawed because code as to be written by someone, and that someone is not impartial.


  • So you are trying to argue that slavery is a RIGHT? This looks like and argument of guilt by association. Authoritarian is seen as bad, by giving the abolishment of slavery the label of “authoritarian” gives of the idea that you want to associate it with being bad.

    If having a law that restricts one’s ability to do something is “authoritarian” then any law is authoritarian, because laws, by definition, determine what behaviour is and isn’t allowed within a society. On that note, morality determines legality, not the other way around.

    Slavery means that, if you’re rich enough, you should be allowed to revoke the rights of others. This is refutable at so many levels. If someone were to “willingly” agree to give up their rights, then just you’re just taking advantage of someone who was born in an unfavourable position and have no other choice other than to accept (and maybe not starve) or starve.